How Google’s ‘Option B’ in the Digital Markets Act Will Transform Travel and Local SEO

Google’s Option B Under the DMA: A Seismic Shift for Travel and Local SEO

The digital marketing landscape is experiencing a major transformation as Google rolls out its “Option B” adjustments to comply with the European Union’s Digital Markets Act (DMA). These changes are fundamentally altering how travel listings and local businesses appear in search results, creating both challenges and opportunities for SEO professionals.

For brands in the travel sector and local businesses targeting European markets, understanding these shifts isn’t just important—it’s essential for survival. The visibility paradigm that many businesses have optimized for is undergoing a radical restructuring, and those who adapt quickly stand to gain significant advantages.

This article will break down exactly what Google’s “Option B” entails, how it’s reshaping the SEO battlefield specifically for travel and local listings, and provide actionable guidance on adapting your strategy for this new reality.

The changes brought by Google’s DMA compliance aren’t just another algorithm update – they represent the most significant restructuring of European search results in a decade, with comparative listing sites gaining unprecedented visibility at the expense of Google’s own features.

Understanding the Digital Markets Act and Google’s Response

The EU’s Digital Markets Act represents one of the most aggressive regulatory interventions in digital markets to date. At its core, the DMA aims to create fairer competition by imposing strict regulations on “gatekeeper” platforms like Google that control access to significant user bases.

After being designated as a gatekeeper, Google was compelled to adjust its practices to comply with the DMA’s requirements. Rather than simply tweaking its existing approach, Google unveiled “Option B” in early 2024, introducing a significant restructuring of its search results page that fundamentally changes how users interact with search results.

The most visible aspect of this change is the new “Comparison Sites” feature appearing prominently in search results for certain categories, including travel and local businesses. This feature showcases aggregator and comparison websites over Google’s previously dominant proprietary features like the Hotel Pack.

Key Elements of Option B That Impact Travel and Local SEO

• Comparison Sites SERP Feature: A new dedicated section appearing in approximately 24% of queries, prominently featuring third-party comparison websites.
• Reduced Visibility of Google’s Own Features: The Google Hotel Pack, traditionally dominant in travel searches, has seen its ranking position visibility drop from 95% to 70% post-implementation.
• Traffic Redistribution: Significant traffic shifts from Google’s proprietary features to third-party aggregators and comparison websites.
• Click-Through Rate Impact: Projected 50-66% drop in CTR for hotels appearing in Google’s Hotel Pack.

The Travel Sector: Ground Zero for Option B’s Impact

The travel industry has been particularly affected by these changes, with hotel and accommodation searches seeing some of the most dramatic shifts in SERP layouts. Prior to the DMA implementation, Google’s Hotel Pack dominated the top positions in almost 95% of travel-related searches, creating a nearly monopolistic control of user clicks.

Post-implementation data tells a starkly different story: Google’s Hotel Pack now appears in top positions in only about 70% of searches, with the newly prominent Comparison Sites feature taking a significant share of prime SERP real estate.

This redistribution of visibility has created a ripple effect throughout the travel search ecosystem:

Winners in the New Landscape

• Online Travel Agencies (OTAs): Major players like Booking.com, Expedia, and TripAdvisor have seen significant visibility gains, appearing both in their traditional organic positions and in the new Comparison Sites feature.
• Metasearch Engines: Platforms specifically focusing on travel comparison (Kayak, Trivago, etc.) have experienced dramatic visibility boosts.
• Review Aggregators: Sites collecting and displaying reviews from multiple sources now receive greater prominence.

Challenges for Direct Hotel Marketers

For individual hotels and hotel chains that had optimized their strategies around appearing in Google’s Hotel Pack, the impact has been concerning. Many are reporting significant traffic reductions as users are now being directed to comparison sites rather than directly to hotel listings.

The projected 50-66% drop in click-through rates for properties appearing in the Hotel Pack represents a substantial challenge for direct bookings. Hotels now face the prospect of paying higher commissions to OTAs or investing more heavily in alternative traffic sources.

Local Business Implications Beyond Travel

While travel has seen the most immediate impact, local businesses across various sectors are also experiencing significant changes in visibility patterns. Like the Hotel Pack, Google’s Local Pack (the map-based local business listings) has seen reduced prominence as comparison and directory sites gain visibility.

This shift has particular implications for:

• Restaurants and Food Services: Directory sites like Yelp, TripAdvisor, and TheFork are gaining prominence over Google’s own restaurant listings.
• Retail Businesses: Product comparison sites are receiving enhanced visibility, potentially reducing direct traffic to local stores.
• Service Providers: Platforms aggregating services (plumbers, electricians, etc.) are seeing boosted rankings.

For small and medium local businesses that had built their online presence primarily through Google Business Profile optimization, these changes necessitate a strategic reassessment. The days of relying exclusively on Google’s proprietary features for visibility appear to be ending in the EU market.

Adapting Your SEO Strategy to the New Reality

With the fundamental structure of search results shifting, businesses need to adapt their SEO approaches accordingly. Here are key strategic adjustments to consider:

1. Embrace a Multi-Platform Approach

The reduced dominance of Google’s own features means businesses must expand their presence across multiple platforms:

• Comprehensive OTA/Directory Coverage: Ensure your business has complete, optimized listings on all relevant comparison sites and directories.
• Optimize for Metasearch: For travel businesses, dedicate resources to appearing effectively on metasearch engines that are gaining prominence.
• Review Management Across Platforms: With review aggregators gaining visibility, maintain active review management across all platforms, not just Google.

2. Recalibrate Content and On-Site SEO

The changing landscape requires adjustments to your content strategy:

• Comparison-Friendly Content: Create content that positions your offering effectively within comparison frameworks—highlight unique selling points that stand out when users compare options.
• Enhanced Structured Data: Implement comprehensive schema markup to help your content appear effectively both in traditional organic results and when pulled into comparison features.
• Authority Building: Develop authoritative content that positions your site as an expert resource, potentially enabling you to appear as a comparison site yourself for relevant searches.

3. Track and Adapt to Changing Metrics

With traffic patterns shifting, metrics monitoring becomes crucial:

• Traffic Source Analysis: Closely monitor changing patterns in referral traffic, particularly from comparison sites gaining prominence.
• SERP Feature Tracking: Implement tools that track both your visibility in traditional organic results and in the new comparison features.
• Conversion Path Analysis: Understand how longer customer journeys (through comparison sites) affect conversion rates and adjust attribution models accordingly.

Specific Tactics for Travel Businesses

For travel businesses specifically, the following tactical approaches can help navigate the new landscape:

Reimagined Rate and Inventory Strategy

With comparison sites gaining prominence, rate parity and inventory distribution strategies require reconsideration:

• Strategic Rate Positioning: Consider how your rates appear when directly compared with competitors across multiple platforms.
• Visible Differentiators: Ensure unique selling points (free breakfasts, no booking fees, etc.) are prominently displayed in comparison listings.
• Distribution Channel Management: Carefully manage which inventory is available through which channels to maximize profitability despite increased comparison shopping.

Direct Booking Incentives

As the path to direct bookings becomes more challenging, strengthen your direct booking value proposition:

• Loyalty Program Enhancement: Offer compelling benefits available only through direct bookings.
• Website Experience Optimization: Ensure your direct booking experience is superior to OTA alternatives in terms of user experience and functionality.
• Post-Comparison Remarketing: Implement sophisticated remarketing strategies targeting users who have viewed your property on comparison sites.

Local Business Adaptation Strategies

Local businesses facing similar challenges can implement these specific approaches:

Directory and Aggregator Optimization

With local directories gaining prominence, optimize your presence accordingly:

• Comprehensive Directory Coverage: Ensure consistent, complete listings across all relevant directories for your business category.
• Enhanced Visual Assets: Invest in high-quality images and videos that stand out in directory listings.
• Review Generation Campaigns: Actively solicit reviews across multiple platforms, not just Google.

Local Content Authority Building

Establish your business as a local authority through strategic content:

• Local Resource Development: Create genuinely useful resources about your local area that can attract links and establish authority.
• Community Engagement Content: Demonstrate local community involvement through content that showcases your business as an integral part of the local ecosystem.
• Expert Positioning: Develop content that establishes your team as local experts in your field, potentially enabling you to appear in featured snippets and other prominent positions.

Measuring the Impact of Option B on Your Business

To effectively navigate these changes, implement robust measurement approaches:

Key Metrics to Track

• Visibility Distribution: Track your appearance across different SERP features (traditional organic, Google features, comparison sites).
• Referral Traffic Shifts: Monitor changes in traffic patterns from different sources.
• Conversion Journey Changes: Analyze how conversion paths and attribution may be changing as users take more comparison-driven journeys.
• Competitive Position Monitoring: Track how your visibility compares to competitors across the new SERP landscape.

Tools for Effective Monitoring

Several tools can help track these evolving metrics:

• SERP Feature Tracking Tools: Advanced SEO platforms that monitor visibility across different SERP features.
• Enhanced Google Analytics Setups: Custom configurations to track changing traffic patterns and attribution models.
• Competitor Analysis Tools: Platforms that compare your visibility against competitors across multiple platforms.

The Broader Implications for Digital Competition

Beyond the immediate tactical considerations, Option B represents a significant shift in the competitive dynamics of digital marketing. Google’s adjustment to the DMA requirements opens opportunities for platforms that had previously struggled against Google’s own features.

This creates a more complex but potentially more diverse digital ecosystem. Businesses that can effectively navigate multiple platforms and comparison environments may find new opportunities for differentiation and visibility that weren’t previously possible.

Furthermore, the changes highlight the increasing importance of regulatory frameworks in shaping digital marketing strategies. As other regions consider similar regulatory approaches, the EU experience with the DMA and Option B may foreshadow more widespread changes to come.

Preparing for What’s Next

While Option B is still in its early implementation stages, forward-thinking businesses should already be considering potential future developments:

• Potential Geographic Expansion: Monitor whether similar changes might be implemented in non-EU markets, either voluntarily by Google or through similar regulatory frameworks.
• Further Feature Evolution: Watch for refinements and adjustments to the comparison features as Google iterates on its DMA compliance approach.
• Competitive Response: Anticipate how traditional organic competitors and platforms might adjust their own strategies in response to the changing landscape.

Conclusion: Embracing the New Competitive Reality

The implementation of Option B under the DMA represents one of the most significant restructurings of Google’s search results in recent history, particularly for travel and local businesses targeting European markets. While the changes present real challenges for businesses that had optimized primarily for Google’s proprietary features, they also create new opportunities for those ready to embrace a multi-platform, comparison-friendly approach.

Success in this new landscape will require greater agility, more sophisticated cross-platform optimization, and careful attention to how your business appears when directly compared with competitors. The businesses that adapt quickly stand to gain significant advantages as the new competitive dynamics solidify.

By implementing the strategies outlined in this article, tracking the right metrics, and remaining flexible as the situation continues to evolve, savvy marketers can turn these regulatory-driven changes into opportunities for growth and enhanced visibility.

The digital marketing landscape has always been characterized by constant change. While the DMA-driven shifts may be more dramatic than most, the fundamental challenge remains the same: adapt, optimize, and find opportunity in disruption.

Stay Ahead with Expert SEO Guidance

Navigating these complex changes requires specialized expertise and cutting-edge strategies. Join the Sapient SEO waitlist today to get priority access to our tailored solutions specifically designed to help your business thrive in this new competitive reality. Our team of experts continuously monitors these evolving dynamics and develops customized approaches that keep you ahead of the curve. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to transform these challenges into your competitive advantage.