The Impact of Deprecated Schema: Should You Act Now?

Deprecated Schema: Should You Remove It Immediately or Wait and See?

Schema deprecations have become more frequent lately, leaving many SEO practitioners caught in a dilemma. Do you immediately strip out deprecated schema types like CourseInfo and VehicleListing from your site, or deploy a more measured wait-and-see approach?

The answer isn’t as straightforward as you might hope. While Google recently announced the end of support for several schema types, the ripple effects on both search visibility and user experience are still developing. This article dives into what you need to know and how to make the right call for your specific situation.

We’ll explore not just the technical SEO implications but also how these changes might affect your users’ interactions with your content in search results—and whether immediate action or strategic patience makes more sense.

Schema deprecation isn’t just a technical checkbox—it represents a fundamental shift in how search engines understand and display your content. The decisions you make now could affect your visibility for months or years to come.

Let’s cut through the confusion and give you actionable insights on navigating these changes effectively.

What Schema Deprecation Actually Means

First, let’s clarify what we’re talking about when we say “deprecated schema.” Schema markup (structured data) helps search engines understand the content of your pages. When a schema type becomes deprecated, it means the search engines—primarily Google—have decided to phase out support for that particular markup format.

The recent deprecations have included:

• CourseInfo: Previously used to highlight educational courses
• VehicleListing: Used by automotive sites to display vehicle details
• Several other specialized schema types that were less commonly implemented

Importantly, deprecation doesn’t mean immediate removal from the search ecosystem. There’s typically a grace period during which old schema continues to function, albeit with diminishing returns over time.

Deprecation vs. Removal: Understanding the Difference

When Google deprecates a schema type, they’re essentially sending a signal that they plan to phase it out—not that it stops working immediately. This distinction is crucial for your decision-making:

• Deprecation: The schema is no longer recommended but may still be processed
• Removal: The schema is completely ignored and provides no benefit

Most deprecations go through a multi-month cycle before full removal occurs. During this transitional period, you have time to evaluate and adjust your approach.

The SEO Impact of Keeping Deprecated Schema

Keeping deprecated schema types on your site isn’t necessarily harmful in the short term, but it does carry certain risks and lost opportunities:

Immediate SEO Consequences

The most obvious impact is the gradual loss of rich results and enhanced SERP features. As support for deprecated schema winds down, you’ll likely see:

• Fewer rich snippets for affected content
• Reduced CTR as your listings become less visually prominent
• Potential competitive disadvantage against sites that have migrated to newer schema types

However, it’s worth noting that the core ranking factors aren’t typically affected by deprecated schema—at least not directly. Your content can still rank well, even without the enhanced presentation that schema provides.

Technical Debt and Future Complications

Beyond immediate search performance, keeping deprecated schema can create technical complications:

• Invalid markup appearing in Search Console reports
• Growing technical debt that becomes harder to clean up later
• Potential confusion for developers who join your team and encounter outdated implementations

The presence of deprecated schema can also make it harder to implement new schema types correctly, as conflicts and contradictions may arise between old and new structured data formats.

User Experience Implications

The decision to keep or remove deprecated schema extends beyond pure SEO considerations—it directly affects how users interact with your content in search results.

The Changing Face of Search Results

As deprecated schema types lose support, the visual presentation of your content in SERPs will change. This can impact:

• User Expectations: People who previously saw rich details for your courses or vehicle listings may now see standard results
• Click Behavior: Without enhanced features, users may gravitate toward competitors who display more detailed information
• First Impressions: The perceived authority and professionalism of your brand can be diminished by less robust search listings

The Alternative Schema Landscape

In many cases, Google doesn’t just deprecate schema types—they replace them with alternatives they consider more effective or standardized. Understanding these replacement options is crucial:

• For CourseInfo, Google now recommends using standard Course schema from Schema.org
• VehicleListing functionality can often be replaced with Product schema combined with vehicle-specific properties

The transition to these alternatives isn’t just about maintaining status quo—it often presents opportunities to enhance your search presence if implemented correctly.

The Case for Immediate Removal

Despite the grace period that typically accompanies schema deprecation, there are compelling reasons to act quickly rather than wait:

Clean Data Benefits

Removing deprecated schema promptly helps maintain the integrity of your structured data implementation:

• Cleaner Search Console reports with fewer warnings and errors
• More accurate tracking of schema performance metrics
• Reduced risk of conflicting signals being sent to search engines

Resource Allocation Advantages

There are also practical business reasons to tackle deprecated schema sooner rather than later:

• Development resources can be allocated while the issue is fresh, rather than becoming a forgotten task
• The knowledge of why and how the schema was implemented is likely still available within your team
• Incremental updates are typically less disruptive than major overhauls required after extended delay

For larger sites or organizations with complex approval processes, starting the removal process early allows for proper testing and validation before the deprecated schema stops functioning entirely.

Competitive Edge

Being proactive about schema updates can provide a competitive advantage:

• Early adopters of replacement schema types often see better rich results before the market saturates
• Experimental features and beta implementations from Google tend to favor sites with clean, current structured data
• Resources saved from maintenance of outdated schema can be redirected toward emerging markup opportunities

The Wait-and-See Approach: When Patience Pays Off

Despite the benefits of immediate action, there are legitimate scenarios where a more measured approach makes sense:

Resource Constraints

For teams with limited development resources, prioritization becomes essential:

• If deprecated schema isn’t generating errors or warnings, it may be reasonable to defer updates
• Sites with critical development backlogs might need to prioritize user-facing improvements over schema maintenance
• Small businesses without dedicated SEO staff may need time to research and implement alternatives properly

Monitoring the Transition Period

A strategic wait-and-see approach isn’t about ignoring the deprecation—it’s about gathering data:

• Tracking how competitors adapt can provide insights into effective alternative implementations
• Observing changes in rich result appearance helps quantify the actual impact on your specific content
• Allowing time for Google to refine their guidance, which often evolves after initial deprecation announcements

This approach works best when you establish clear monitoring protocols and set specific triggers for action rather than indefinitely deferring the work.

Making the Decision: A Framework for Action

To determine whether immediate removal or a wait-and-see approach is right for you, consider these key factors:

Site Evaluation Criteria

Practical Steps for Either Approach

Regardless of which path you choose, certain steps are essential:

1. Inventory Your Schema: Conduct a comprehensive audit of all schema types currently implemented across your site
2. Quantify Current Value: Measure the traffic and conversions currently being driven by content with deprecated schema
3. Research Alternatives: Identify the recommended replacement schema types and evaluate implementation requirements
4. Set Timeline Triggers: Establish specific dates or performance thresholds that will prompt action if you’re taking a wait-and-see approach

Implementation Best Practices

When you do decide to remove deprecated schema, follow these best practices to ensure a smooth transition:

Technical Implementation Guidance

• Use a staged approach for large sites, updating sections incrementally to monitor impact
• Implement and test replacement schema on staging environments before pushing to production
• Validate all new schema implementations using Google’s Rich Results Test and Schema.org validators
• Monitor Search Console for errors or warnings related to the transition

Documentation is crucial during this process—maintain clear records of what was changed, when, and why to support future schema management efforts.

Monitoring and Measurement

After making changes to your schema implementation, thorough monitoring helps confirm success:

• Track rich result impression and click rates before and after schema changes
• Monitor ranking positions for affected pages to identify any unexpected shifts
• Set up regular structured data validation checks to catch any implementation issues
• Compare user behavior metrics (bounce rate, time on site, conversion rate) for traffic from search results

Future-Proofing Your Schema Strategy

Beyond addressing current deprecations, a forward-thinking approach to schema can reduce future disruptions:

Creating a Sustainable Schema Architecture

Build your structured data implementation with flexibility in mind:

• Use a modular approach that separates schema implementation from core content management
• Document schema dependencies and relationships to facilitate easier updates
• Consider implementing schema through a tag management system for more agile modifications
• Regularly review Schema.org updates and Google documentation for early signals of future changes

Staying Ahead of Deprecation Cycles

Proactive monitoring can help you anticipate changes before they’re officially announced:

• Subscribe to Google Search Central updates and communications
• Participate in SEO communities where early observations of SERP changes are shared
• Monitor changes in Google’s documentation, as subtle updates often precede formal deprecation announcements
• Track schema usage patterns in your vertical to identify emerging best practices

Conclusion: Balancing Technical Debt Against Immediate Needs

The question of whether to immediately remove deprecated schema or take a wait-and-see approach ultimately comes down to balancing technical debt against immediate business priorities.

For most sites, a hybrid approach makes the most sense: plan for removal while monitoring actual impact, prioritizing the most valuable pages first. This balanced strategy acknowledges both the importance of maintaining clean structured data and the reality of limited resources.

Remember that schema implementation isn’t just a technical SEO task—it’s about how your content appears to potential visitors in search results. The best decisions will consider both the technical implications and the user experience impact of your structured data choices.

By approaching schema deprecation strategically rather than reactively, you can turn what seems like an inconvenience into an opportunity to refine your structured data implementation and potentially gain advantages over less-prepared competitors.

Ready to optimize your schema strategy?

Join the Sapient SEO waitlist today and get early access to our advanced schema management tools, helping you stay ahead of deprecation cycles and maximize your rich result opportunities in search.